Post-Publication Discussion
DINAMIKA: Jurnal Kajian Pendidikan dan Keislaman encourages scholarly discussion and constructive criticism of published articles to promote academic dialogue, clarify research findings, and advance knowledge in education and Islamic studies.
|
Submission of Comments and Discussions |
Readers and researchers may submit comments, questions, or scholarly critiques concerning published articles through the journal’s official contact channel. Submissions must identify the article and explain the issues raised, supported by relevant evidence or references where appropriate. |
|
Editorial Assessment |
The editor evaluates submissions based on scholarly relevance, originality, accuracy, clarity, and compliance with publication ethics. The editor may request revisions, consult experts, or decline submissions that lack academic merit. |
|
Right of Reply |
Authors of the original article may be invited to respond to substantive comments or criticisms. Responses should address the issues objectively and provide appropriate scholarly evidence. |
|
Publication of Discussions |
Accepted comments and responses may be published as a Letter to the Editor, commentary, or another appropriate scholarly format, subject to editorial assessment and peer review where necessary. |
|
Linking to Published Articles |
Published comments and responses should identify and link to the original article to maintain transparency and provide readers with the context of the discussion. |
|
Corrections and Research Integrity |
If a discussion raises credible concerns about errors, research methods, findings, or ethical violations, the editor will assess the matter under the relevant journal policies. Corrections and retractions are governed by the Retraction and Correction Policy, while suspected misconduct is handled under the Allegations of Research Misconduct Policy. |
|
Ethical Responsibilities |
Contributors must ensure that their comments are accurate, respectful, evidence-based, and properly referenced. Relevant competing interests must be disclosed. Personal attacks, defamatory statements, and unsupported allegations are unacceptable. |
|
Submission Channel |
Comments and responses should be submitted through the official contact channel listed on the DINAMIKA journal website, together with the relevant article details and supporting references where applicable. |
All post-publication discussions will be handled fairly, transparently, and impartially. The final editorial decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or a designated editor without a relevant conflict of interest, in accordance with the journal’s publication ethics policies and applicable COPE guidance.
